Thu. Dec 12th, 2024
CLAT 2025 Study material
About Lesson

The Law of Torts deals with civil wrongs and remedies, offering protection against infringement of rights or harm caused by wrongful acts. It plays a crucial role in ensuring accountability and redressal for injuries. Below is a comprehensive explanation of the key concepts under tort law. 

  1. Definition of Tort
  • Tort: A civil wrong that causes harm or injury to another, leading to legal liability.
  • The term “tort” originates from the Latin word “tortum”, meaning twisted or crooked, signifying a deviation from lawful behavior.

Key Characteristics of a Tort

  1. Civil Wrong: Distinct from crimes and breaches of contract.
  2. Breach of Legal Duty: Involves violation of a duty imposed by law.
  3. Remedies: Victim can seek compensation or other remedies in civil courts.
  1. Essentials of a Tort

To establish liability in tort, the following elements must be proven:

  1. Wrongful Act or Omission
  • There must be a wrongful act or omission that infringes another’s rights.
  1. Legal Duty
  • The defendant must owe a legal duty of care to the plaintiff.
  1. Causation
  • There must be a direct link between the wrongful act and the injury caused (cause-in-fact).
  1. Damages
  • Actual harm, injury, or loss must have occurred as a result of the wrongful act.
  1. General Principles of Tortious Liability
  2. Fault-Based Liability
  • Liability arises when harm is caused due to negligence, intention, or carelessness.
  1. Strict Liability (Rylands v. Fletcher, 1868)
  • A person may be held liable even without fault, provided certain conditions are met:
    • Use of Dangerous Substances: Defendant brings a dangerous thing onto their land.
    • Escape: The substance escapes and causes harm.
    • Non-Natural Use of Land: Activity must be unusual for the area.
    • Exception: Act of God, plaintiff’s fault, or statutory authority.
  1. Absolute Liability
  • Evolved in M.C. Mehta v. Union of India (1987) (Oleum Gas Leak Case).
  • Liability for harm caused by hazardous activities is absolute, with no exceptions.
  1. Types of Torts
  2. Torts Against Persons
  1. Assault: Threat of imminent harm without physical contact.
  2. Battery: Intentional physical contact causing harm or offense.
  3. False Imprisonment: Unlawful restriction of a person’s freedom of movement.
  1. Torts Against Property
  1. Trespass to Land: Unlawful entry onto another’s property.
  2. Nuisance: Interference with another’s enjoyment of property (public or private).
  1. Torts Against Reputation
  1. Defamation: False statements harming a person’s reputation.
    • Libel: Written or permanent form.
    • Slander: Spoken or temporary form.
  1. Economic Torts
  1. Deceit: Misrepresentation causing financial harm.
  2. Inducing Breach of Contract: Persuading someone to break a contract.
  1. Defenses in Tort Law

The defendant can invoke the following defenses to avoid liability:

  1. Volenti Non Fit Injuria (Consent)
  • No liability arises if the plaintiff consented to the harm.
  • Example: Injuries sustained during a lawful boxing match.
  1. Contributory Negligence
  • The plaintiff’s negligence contributed to the harm suffered.
  • Example: A pedestrian ignoring traffic signals and getting hit.
  1. Act of God (Vis Major)
  • Harm caused by natural forces beyond human control.
  • Example: Damage due to an earthquake.
  1. Inevitable Accident
  • Harm caused despite reasonable care and caution.
  1. Necessity
  • An act done to prevent greater harm.
  1. Remedies in Tort Law
  2. Judicial Remedies
  1. Damages: Monetary compensation for harm suffered.
    • Nominal Damages: Token compensation for legal wrongs without significant harm.
    • Compensatory Damages: To compensate for actual loss or injury.
    • Punitive Damages: To punish the defendant for egregious conduct.
  2. Injunction: Court order restraining a party from continuing wrongful acts.
  3. Specific Restitution: Return of property wrongfully taken or withheld.
  1. Extra-Judicial Remedies
  1. Self-Help: Lawful defense of property or person.
  2. Abatement of Nuisance: Removing the source of nuisance.
  1. Landmark Cases in Tort Law
  2. Rylands v. Fletcher (1868)
  • Established the rule of strict liability for hazardous activities.
  1. Donoghue v. Stevenson (1932)
  • Introduced the principle of duty of care in negligence cases.
  1. M.C. Mehta v. Union of India (1987)
  • Expanded strict liability to absolute liability for hazardous industries.
  1. Ashby v. White (1703)
  • Reinforced that every legal injury has a remedy (Ubi jus ibi remedium).
  1. Gloucester Grammar School Case (1410)
  • Held that lawful acts causing harm do not constitute torts (principle of damnum sine injuria).
  1. Important Legal Maxims in Tort Law
  1. Ubi Jus Ibi Remedium: Where there is a right, there is a remedy.
  2. Damnum Sine Injuria: Damage without legal injury (e.g., lawful competition).
  3. Injuria Sine Damno: Legal injury without actual damage (e.g., voting rights denied).
  1. Application of Tort Law in Modern Context
  • Consumer Protection: Redressal for defective goods and services.
  • Environmental Law: Cases involving pollution and ecological damage (e.g., Bhopal Gas Tragedy).
  • Medical Negligence: Legal actions against doctors or hospitals for malpractice.
  • Corporate Torts: Liability for acts like fraud, misrepresentation, and unfair trade practices.
  1. Tort Law in Indian Context
  • Codified vs. Uncodified Law: Tort law in India remains largely uncodified but is influenced by English common law.
  • Statutory Provisions: Consumer Protection Act, 2019; Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.
  • Judicial Activism: Indian courts have expanded tort law to include environmental protection, consumer rights, and more.

Conclusion

The Law of Torts is a dynamic branch of law that ensures justice for civil wrongs, balancing individual rights with social responsibilities. Its principles, defenses, and remedies form a critical part of CLAT’s legal reasoning and general awareness sections. Understanding its nuances and landmark cases will prepare you well for the examination.